ResearchBlogging

A Review of The BCA's Evidence for Chiropractic

ResearchBlogging.org Well over a year after Simon Singh's 'libelous' article on Chiropractic was published; with Singh preparing to launch an appeal against Eady's ruling in the preliminary hearing of the result trial; and with the chiropractic profession under siege from a PR nightmare; the British Chiropractic Association have finally decided to release the evidence that they claim backs up their promotion of chiropractic treatments. In doing so, they have misrepresented evidence.

Your rating: None Average: 4.8 (8 votes)

Misunderstanding Acupuncture Studies

In recent weeks myself and a few others have engaged with some CAM practitioners via Twitter, and one of the things that keeps coming up is a version of the following argument:

CAM Dude: "This study supports my therapy!"
Scientists: "No it doesn't!"
CAM Dude: "Yes it does!"

And so on ad infinitum. The problem seems to come down to a lack of understanding of methodology, so in this post I'm going to walk through a study cited by "drmike001" as supporting acupuncture, and describe what they can and can't show, and what would have to be done to really support the conclusions that he wants to arrive at.

Your rating: None Average: 3 (1 vote)

Burma - How an Early Warning from Science was Ignored

ResearchBlogging.org

It was the most disasterous cyclone-hit in recent times. Over 140,000 people have been confirmed dead with tens of thousands more missing and millions rendered homeless, mostly in the low lying Irrawaddy delta region on the Burmese coast, where even one year on, survivors are facing deficits of foot, water, shelter and sanitation, and the UN have only recently been granted significant access. The damage was done not by the winds of "Cyclone Nargis" however, but by a tidal surge more than ten feet high that swept across the land. It's tempting to attribute such disasters to bad luck, but in fact this was at least partly preventable, and scientists explained exactly why in 2005 in the research that I'll show you now for my first regular post at worldismycountry.org - Dahdouhguebas et al's "How effective were mangroves as a defence against the recent tsunami?" [1].

Continue reading at WorldIsMyCountry.org.

Your rating: None Average: 4 (1 vote)

Torture: Does it Really Work?

In the current debate over the Bush administration's use of torture, most of the discussion has been around the moral and ethical dilemmas involved, with the strongest argument in favour being the infamous 'ticking bomb' scenario. But in fact these arguments and make-believe situations are irrelevent if torture doesn't work in the first place.

In the first of my new weekly posts on evidence-based policy for the UK politics blog Liberal Conspiracy, I want to explore the evidence for torture, because if those who advocate it can't prove that it works, then they have already lost the debate.

Continue reading at Liberal Conspiracy.

No votes yet

Factors Behind the Relentless Spread of the Alt-Med Meme

ResearchBlogging.org

[bpsdb] You won't hear practitioners say it - it would spoil their underdog, anti-establishment vibe - but alternative medicine is big business, pulling in over US$60billion a year. In many countries, alt med is primary healthcare. Unsurprisingly, those tend not to be the healthiest countries. The thing is, as Tim Minchin astutely observes in his poem 'Storm': "By definition, alternative medicine has either not been proved to work, or been proved not to work. Do you know what they call alternative medicine that's been proved to work? ... Medicine" So why do such lousy treatments remain so popular? The authors of a recent PLoS paper, "From Traditional Medicine to Witchcraft: Why Medical Treatments Are Not Always Efficacious," have one intriguing idea [1].

No votes yet

National Center for Homeopathy's Creative Use of Peer Reviewed Research (1 of 4)

ResearchBlogging.org[bpsdb] When I blogged about the adventures of homeopath Jeremy Sherr recently, a couple of people leapt to the defense of his dubious trade. In particular, one poster called "Prolix" made the following challenge: "...skeptics fail to report the studies and meta-analyses which report positive outcome The National Center for Homeopathy has compiled a list of them. It's important to look at the evidence BOTH sides of an argument, not just the side you favor."

I'm grateful to Prolix, because the resource he cited neatly demonstrates why scientists have so little time for homeopathy, and indeed find many homeopaths to be fundamentally dishonest people. In this four part case study over the next few weeks, I'll take you through the NCH's use of peer reviewed research, and try to explain where they've gone so badly wrong.

No votes yet

Catching Snowflakes: The Media and Public Perceptions of Disease

ResearchBlogging.orgIt's repeated so often that it has long been regarded as a cliche, but we live in an increasingly information-intensive world, bombarded by facts and figures from an endless queue of media outlets, websites, television shows and Windsor-based science bloggers. This abundance of information often comes with a cost. If my grandfather wanted to learn something about his health - and of course like many men of his generation he didn't - he would have seen a doctor or read a reputable book. These days, we receive much of our information on the fly in bite-sized chunks from websites and media articles. Fast food culture applied to research.

The result is like trying to build an igloo by catching snowflakes. We snatch little snippets of information here and there, but often they lack any real substance, failing to really contribute to the building of a complete understanding of a subject. Stripped of context or reference, in the end these factlets are as intangible as the ether they travel through.

Your rating: None Average: 3 (1 vote)

The 2nd Giants' Shoulders

So hello and welcome (slightly later than planned due to a roof-leak emergency) to the 2nd edition of The Giants' Shoulders. Uniquely for 2008, this edition comes a full 31 days after the last, and 31 days before the next. Isn't that interesting? No? Well maybe these bloggers will be. Presented in date order, here are the best recent(ish, since we're in the early days of the carnival still) posts on historical(ish) peer reviewed research, in no particular order other than by date.

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)

The Birth of Maggot Therapy

ResearchBlogging.org In 1917, at the height of the Great War, William Baer made a chance, startling discovery. The result was his exploration of a novel form of treatment, one that - while somewhat grim to contemplate, is still used today. His experiences and early experiments are described in this paper, "The Treatment of Chronic Osteomyelitis with the Maggot (Larva of the Blow Fly)" [1].

Your rating: None Average: 5 (2 votes)

MMR: The Roles of Education and the Media in Vaccine Uptake

ResearchBlogging.org The controversy over MMR that Andrew Wakefield managed to trigger in the U.K. with his botched Lancet study, has given researchers the opportunity to study the dynamics of a public health scare. Their report, "Anatomy of a Health Scare: Education, Income and the MMR Controversy in the UK" studies the relationship between the media, certain family attributes, and uptake of the MMR vaccine [1]. Their findings call into question conventional wisdom regarding the positive role of parent education in vaccine uptake.

No votes yet

Wikio - Top BlogsCurrent CO2 level in the atmosphere